Disclaimer

The content of this blog is my personal opinion only. Although I am an employee - currently of Imagination Technologies's MIPS group, in the past of other companies such as Intellectual Ventures, Intel, AMD, Motorola, and Gould - I reveal this only so that the reader may account for any possible bias I may have towards my employer's products. The statements I make here in no way represent my employer's position, nor am I authorized to speak on behalf of my employer. In fact, this posting may not even represent my personal opinion, since occasionally I play devil's advocate.

See http://docs.google.com/View?id=dcxddbtr_23cg5thdfj for photo credits.

Thursday, June 03, 2010

Dell streak dimensions - the new PalmPilot?

Many folks are complaining about the Dell Streak, e.g. Dell Streak is not the droid you are looking for | ZDNet.  They say "why would you want a cell phone this big?"

I just watched one of the many Youtube videos (Dell Streak: The versatile 5-inch Android tablet ), and I'm not so sure.  I may *want* this beast.

It looked remarkably like my old, much beloved, PalmPilot, sitting in the demonstrator's hand.  So I looked up the sizes:


productdimensionsweight
Pilot 1000120x80x18 mm160 g
PalmPilot Personal4.7x3.1x.7 in5.6 oz
PalmPilot Professional117x81x17 mm
4.6x3.2x.7 in
6.0 oz
Palm III81x119x18 mm160g
5.6 oz
Kyocera 6035
1st SmartPhone?
14.2x6.6x2.2 mm
5.6x2.6x.86 in
208g
7.34 oz
Dell Streak153x79x10mm
6x3.1x0.4 in
220g
iPhone4.4x2.4x0.46 in
115x61x11.6 mm
4.8 oz
135g
iPad242.8x189.7x13.4 mm
9.56x7.47x13.4 in
680-730g
1.5-1.6 lb

The largest screen that can fit into a man’s shirt pocket.” That’s how Dell executive Ron Garriques described the Streak which was showcased at the D: All Things Digital conference according to a CNet report.

The Dell Streak is almost the same size as my much beloved PalmPilot and, in particular, my old Kyocera phone. I _loved_ those devices. I would still be using my Kyocera - the original, pre-Microsoft, SmartPhone - except for coverage problems.

True, the Dell Streak is longer than my much beloved PalmPilot and my old Kyocera phone. Can you tell that I loved those devices? In particular, it is longer. I do wish that they did not need quite so much bezel, quite so much non-display; I do wish that the display could go much closer to the edge of the top surface. Sure, there has to be a place to put the display logic and drivers, but could not some smart packaging engineer figure out how to fold them under the display?

My biggest concern is not size, but passivity: one of the big reasons I loved my PalmPilot and, then, later, the Kyocera SmartPhone, was that it was a pleasure to enter data into it using the stylus and Graffiti. For several years they were my primary means of keeping track of addresses, to-do items, etc. - basically, they were my PDA! And I haven't had a PDA anywhere near as good since my Kyocera bit the dust, even though I have gone through several smartphones. My Ming A1200 with its stylus came close, but it was not BIG enough to be a good PDA. I doubt that the on-screen keyboard will cut it.

In any case - I look forward to trying the Dell Streak out in person. I hope that there will be some scribbling/handwriting app available, even if I have to write with my finger.

---

Here's a dream: something the size of the Dell Streak, although perhaps a bit smaller. Multitouch, but also stylus (how?). Also touch on the backside, like the Motorola BackFlip (which my wife loves) (how to use touch both front and back, I am not sure - movement?).

1 comment:

AndyGlew said...

The Dell Streak has inspired the first real gadget lust I have experienced in quite a while. More than my lust for iPad (which is more begrudging, sympathy gadget lust - well, yeah, I'd like an iPad if there is not anything better aroun), greater than or equal to my lust for the iPhone.

It got me googling looking for comparables.

Which found me another gadget to lust over - the Kno dual screen tablet. Tegra, TWO 14.1" displays, 1440x900. Reviews say it has software problems, but if they work those out...

My next purchase will probably be more like the Streak than the Kno - I need a phone upgrade more, since my Ming became unreliable. But the Know is very tempting.

Wishlist:

I wish the Kno could accept video input, so I could use it as big external displays for the Windows PC I am forced to carry for work, as well as a tablet.

Offline usage - which I expect it has.